Skip to content
FareTell

New York to Montego Bay EWR, JFK, LGA → MBJ

Newark Liberty International Airport (EWR), John F. Kennedy International Airport (JFK), LaGuardia Airport (LGA) → Sangster International Airport (MBJ)

The cheapest return found recently is $394 with United Airlines, 22 Jan 2027 – 29 Jan 2027, found 15 hours ago. The cheapest one-way found recently is $177 with Air Canada, 28 Nov, found today.

Return

The cheapest return fare on each of 6 departure dates is usually $397 to $492.

Cheapest return found recently

$394

22 Jan 2027 – 29 Jan 2027 · United Airlines

Newark Liberty International Airport (EWR) → Sangster International Airport (MBJ)

Leaves 10:05 a.m. · Return leaves 1:25 p.m. · 8 h 9 min of travel, both ways together

out nonstop, back nonstop

found 15 hours ago

See prices for these datesCheck today's price

Cheapest nonstop return

$394

22 Jan 2027 – 29 Jan 2027 · United Airlines

Newark Liberty International Airport (EWR) → Sangster International Airport (MBJ)

Leaves 10:05 a.m. · Return leaves 1:25 p.m. · 8 h 9 min of travel, both ways together

out nonstop, back nonstop

found 15 hours ago

See prices for these datesCheck today's price

FareTell may earn a commission when you book through a partner.

Found recently, and the cheapest we hold

Cheapest found recently $394 22 Jan 2027 – 29 Jan 2027found 15 hours agoSee prices for these dates

Cheapest we hold, of any age $368 28 Nov – 3 Decfound 5 days agoSee prices for these dates

What have prices looked like?

Over 25 days, 24 Sept to 18 Oct, the cheapest return we saw each day was $244 to $425.

$394, the cheapest return found recently, sits here in that range of $244 to $425.

25 days is a short history, so treat this range as an early guide.

Those were the prices on those days, not today's.

Is this a good return price?

Compared with the cheapest return fare on each of 6 departure dates from 11 Nov to 10 Aug 2027, found by travelers' searches in the last 7 days (economy, the price the seller showed on Aviasales). The usual range is the middle half of those prices.

Could nearby dates be cheaper?

We hold no other 7-night return fares leaving within 3 days of 22 Jan 2027 to compare.

Every date we hold

148 fares on 6 departure dates

11 Nov – 14 Nov: $458, found yesterday21 Nov – 25 Nov: $516, found today24 Nov – 4 Dec: $404, found 5 days ago28 Nov – 3 Dec: $368, found 5 days ago22 Jan 2027 – 29 Jan 2027: $394, found 15 hours ago10 Aug 2027 – 24 Aug 2027: $503, found 6 days agoNovJanAug
See the chart as a table
The cheapest price seen for each departure date — per traveler in Economy.
DatesFromAirlineAirportsStopsFound
11 Nov – 14 Nov$458United AirlinesNewark Liberty International Airport (EWR) → Sangster International Airport (MBJ)out nonstop, back 1 stopfound yesterdaySee prices for these dates
21 Nov – 25 Nov$516jetBlueJohn F. Kennedy International Airport (JFK) → Sangster International Airport (MBJ)out nonstop, back nonstopfound todaySee prices for these dates
24 Nov – 4 Dec$404jetBlueJohn F. Kennedy International Airport (JFK) → Sangster International Airport (MBJ)out nonstop, back nonstopfound 5 days agoSee prices for these dates
28 Nov – 3 Dec$368United AirlinesNewark Liberty International Airport (EWR) → Sangster International Airport (MBJ)out nonstop, back nonstopfound 5 days agoSee prices for these dates
22 Jan 2027 – 29 Jan 2027$394United AirlinesNewark Liberty International Airport (EWR) → Sangster International Airport (MBJ)out nonstop, back nonstopfound 15 hours agoSee prices for these dates
10 Aug 2027 – 24 Aug 2027$503American AirlinesJohn F. Kennedy International Airport (JFK) → Sangster International Airport (MBJ)out 1 stop, back 1 stopfound 6 days agoSee prices for these dates

Which month looks cheapest?

November 2026 is the cheapest month — from $368.

November 2026From $368Cheapest seen4 departure dates28 Nov – 3 Dec · found 5 days agoSee prices for these dates
January 2027From $3941 departure date22 Jan 2027 – 29 Jan 2027 · found 15 hours agoSee prices for these dates
August 2027From $5031 departure date10 Aug 2027 – 24 Aug 2027 · found 6 days agoSee prices for these dates

Airlines on the cheapest dates: United Airlines, jetBlue, American Airlines.

One-way

The cheapest one-way fare on each of 4 departure dates is usually $166 to $187.

Cheapest one-way found recently

$177

28 Nov · Air Canada

LaGuardia Airport (LGA) → Sangster International Airport (MBJ)

Leaves 5:35 p.m. · 19 h 50 min trip

1 stop

found today

Open this tripCheck today's price

Cheapest nonstop one-way

$202

28 Nov · United Airlines

Newark Liberty International Airport (EWR) → Sangster International Airport (MBJ)

Leaves 8:39 a.m. · 4 h 9 min trip

nonstop

found 8 hours ago

Open this tripCheck today's price

FareTell may earn a commission when you book through a partner.

Found recently, and the cheapest we hold

Cheapest found recently $177 28 Novfound todayOpen this trip

Cheapest we hold, of any age $149 25 Octfound 3 days agoOpen this trip

What have prices looked like?

Over 16 days, 24 Sept to 18 Oct, the cheapest one-way we saw each day was $149 to $216.

$177, the cheapest one-way found recently, sits here in that range of $149 to $216.

16 days is a short history, so treat this range as an early guide.

Those were the prices on those days, not today's.

Is this a good one-way price?

Compared with the cheapest one-way fare on each of 4 departure dates from 25 Oct to 29 May 2027, found by travelers' searches in the last 7 days (economy, the price the seller showed on Aviasales). The usual range is the middle half of those prices.

Could nearby dates be cheaper?

We hold no other one-way fares leaving within 3 days of 28 Nov to compare.

Every date we hold

51 fares on 4 departure dates

25 Oct: $149, found 3 days ago28 Nov: $177, found today31 Mar 2027: $172, found 3 days ago29 May 2027: $215, found 6 days agoOctNovMarMay
See the chart as a table
The cheapest price seen for each departure date — per traveler in Economy.
DatesFromAirlineAirportsStopsFound
25 Oct$149Frontier AirlinesLaGuardia Airport (LGA) → Sangster International Airport (MBJ)1 stopfound 3 days agoOpen this trip
28 Nov$177Air CanadaLaGuardia Airport (LGA) → Sangster International Airport (MBJ)1 stopfound todayOpen this trip
31 Mar 2027$172United AirlinesNewark Liberty International Airport (EWR) → Sangster International Airport (MBJ)1 stopfound 3 days agoOpen this trip
29 May 2027$215United AirlinesNewark Liberty International Airport (EWR) → Sangster International Airport (MBJ)1 stopfound 6 days agoOpen this trip

Which month looks cheapest?

October 2026 is the cheapest month — from $149.

October 2026From $149Cheapest seen1 departure date25 Oct · found 3 days agoOpen this trip
November 2026From $1771 departure date28 Nov · found todayOpen this trip
March 2027From $1721 departure date31 Mar 2027 · found 3 days agoOpen this trip
May 2027From $2151 departure date29 May 2027 · found 6 days agoOpen this trip

Airlines on the cheapest dates: United Airlines, Frontier Airlines, Air Canada.

Premium cabin fares from New York to Montego Bay

We hold no premium economy, business or first-class fares for this route: we collect them for the busiest routes, and this one is not among them yet.

Today's prices for 22 Jan 2027 – 29 Jan 2027 in another cabin: Premium economy · Business · First

Today's prices for 28 Nov in another cabin: Premium economy · Business · First

How far ahead were prices cheapest for New York to Montego Bay?

Return

Fares 30 to 59 days before departure were typically 34% lower than 0 to 6 days before departure.

From the cheapest return each day between 24 Sept and 18 Oct (25 days), grouped by how many days ahead the flight left; one adult in economy.

Each range covers different departure dates, so this compares typical fares, not the same trip priced twice.

Prices reflect recent searches — current fares may differ.

See these ranges as a table
Typical price in each booking range — round trip, per traveler in Economy.
Booked ahead byTypical fareCheapest dayAbove the cheapestDays of prices
0–6 days$533$514+51%10
7–13 days$514$321+46%7
14–29 days$467$321+33%16
30–59 days$352$244Cheapest seen24
60–89 days$619$400+76%21
90–179 days$393$363+12%21
180+ days$503$422+43%22

One-way

Not enough history yet: in 16 days of one-way prices, 24 Sept to 18 Oct, fewer than 3 booking ranges had prices on 7 days or more.

Could a nearby airport be cheaper?

A different airport at either end can change the fare — sometimes a lot.

Return

Newburgh → Montego Bay

88 km from New York

$504

$110 more than flying from New York

21 Nov – 25 Nov · SWF → MBJ · out 3 stops, back nonstop

found today

See this route

Philadelphia → Montego Bay

130 km from New York

$666

$272 more than flying from New York

16 Nov – 6 Jan 2027 · PHL → MBJ · out 1 stop, back 2 stops

found yesterday

See this route

New York → Kingston

125 km from Montego Bay

$953

$559 more than flying to Montego Bay

19 Dec – 5 Jan 2027 · EWR → KIN · out 1 stop, back 1 stop

found yesterday

See this route

Cheapest recent price on each route — round trip, per traveler in Economy. Distances are in a straight line.

One-way

Philadelphia → Montego Bay

130 km from New York

$341

$164 more than flying from New York

15 Dec · PHL → MBJ · 1 stop

found 5 days ago

See this route

Newburgh → Montego Bay

88 km from New York

$472

$295 more than flying from New York

28 Nov · SWF → MBJ · 1 stop

found today

See this route

Cheapest recent price on each route — one way, per traveler in Economy. Distances are in a straight line.

Live price for these dates

The cheapest return found recently is for 22 Jan 2027 – 29 Jan 2027. A live search on this page shows what those dates cost now, for one adult in economy.

Prices are what travelers' searches on Aviasales found in the last 7 days, in US dollars: the price the seller showed on Aviasales; bags may cost extra. Fares change, so check today's price before you book. How our prices work