Skip to content
FareTell

New York to Toronto flights in December 2026 from $96 EWR, JFK, LGA → YHM, YTZ, YYZ

Newark Liberty International Airport (EWR), John F. Kennedy International Airport (JFK), LaGuardia Airport (LGA) → Hamilton Airport (YHM), Toronto City Centre Airport (YTZ), Pearson International Airport (YYZ)

For departures in December 2026, the cheapest return found recently is $218 with Porter Airlines Canada, 1 Dec – 6 Dec, found 2 days ago. The cheapest one-way found recently is $96 with Porter Airlines Canada, 1 Dec, found 4 hours ago.

Return

In December 2026, the cheapest return fare on each of 5 departure dates is usually $220 to $253. Across all 16 departure dates we hold on this route, it is usually $221 to $321. Of the 3 months with enough return fares to compare, December 2026 is usually the cheapest.

Cheapest return found recently

$218

1 Dec – 6 Dec · Porter Airlines Canada

LaGuardia Airport (LGA) → Pearson International Airport (YYZ)

out nonstop, back 1 stop

found 2 days ago

See prices for these datesCheck today's price

It is also the cheapest return we hold, of any age.

FareTell may earn a commission when you book through a partner.

The cheapest dates in December 2026

DatesFromAirlineStopsFound
1 Dec – 6 Dec$218Porter Airlines Canadaout nonstop, back 1 stopfound 2 days agoSee prices for these dates
15 Dec – 22 Dec$220Porter Airlines Canadaout 1 stop, back 1 stopfound 3 days agoSee prices for these dates
28 Dec – 30 Dec$221Porter Airlines Canadaout nonstop, back 1 stopfound 2 days agoSee prices for these dates
25 Dec – 19 Jan 2027$253Porter Airlines Canadaout nonstop, back 1 stopfound 4 days agoSee prices for these dates
16 Dec – 9 Jan 2027$270Porter Airlines Canadaout 1 stop, back 1 stopfound 6 days agoSee prices for these dates

Every date we hold

5 departure dates

1 Dec – 6 Dec: $218, found 2 days ago15 Dec – 22 Dec: $220, found 3 days ago16 Dec – 9 Jan 2027: $270, found 6 days ago25 Dec – 19 Jan 2027: $253, found 4 days ago28 Dec – 30 Dec: $221, found 2 days agoDec
See the chart as a table
The cheapest price seen for each departure date — per traveler in Economy.
DatesFromAirlineAirportsStopsFound
1 Dec – 6 Dec$218Porter Airlines CanadaLaGuardia Airport (LGA) → Pearson International Airport (YYZ)out nonstop, back 1 stopfound 2 days agoSee prices for these dates
15 Dec – 22 Dec$220Porter Airlines CanadaNewark Liberty International Airport (EWR) → Toronto City Centre Airport (YTZ)out 1 stop, back 1 stopfound 3 days agoSee prices for these dates
16 Dec – 9 Jan 2027$270Porter Airlines CanadaNewark Liberty International Airport (EWR) → Toronto City Centre Airport (YTZ)out 1 stop, back 1 stopfound 6 days agoSee prices for these dates
25 Dec – 19 Jan 2027$253Porter Airlines CanadaNewark Liberty International Airport (EWR) → Toronto City Centre Airport (YTZ)out nonstop, back 1 stopfound 4 days agoSee prices for these dates
28 Dec – 30 Dec$221Porter Airlines CanadaNewark Liberty International Airport (EWR) → Toronto City Centre Airport (YTZ)out nonstop, back 1 stopfound 2 days agoSee prices for these dates

Which month looks cheapest?

November 2026 is the cheapest month — from $213.

November 2026From $213Cheapest seen6 departure dates23 Nov – 1 Dec · found 4 days agoSee prices for these dates
December 2026From $2185 departure dates1 Dec – 6 Dec · found 2 days agoSee prices for these dates
January 2027From $2184 departure dates16 Jan 2027 – 18 Jan 2027 · found 3 days agoSee prices for these dates
February 2027From $3191 departure date14 Feb 2027 – 5 Mar 2027 · found 5 days agoSee prices for these dates

One-way

In December 2026, the cheapest one-way fare on each of 7 departure dates is usually $98 to $104. Across all 19 departure dates we hold on this route, it is usually $99 to $135. Of the 3 months with enough one-way fares to compare, December 2026 is usually the cheapest.

Cheapest one-way found recently

$96

1 Dec · Porter Airlines Canada

Newark Liberty International Airport (EWR) → Pearson International Airport (YYZ)

1 stop

found 4 hours ago

Open this tripCheck today's price

It is also the cheapest one-way we hold, of any age.

FareTell may earn a commission when you book through a partner.

The cheapest dates in December 2026

DatesFromAirlineStopsFound
1 Dec$96Porter Airlines Canada1 stopfound 4 hours agoOpen this trip
6 Dec$97Porter Airlines Canadanonstopfound 2 days agoOpen this trip
15 Dec$98Porter Airlines Canada1 stopfound 3 days agoOpen this trip
29 Dec$99Porter Airlines Canada1 stopfound 2 days agoOpen this trip
16 Dec$103Porter Airlines Canadanonstopfound 3 days agoOpen this trip

Every date we hold

7 departure dates

1 Dec: $96, found 4 hours ago5 Dec: $105, found 7 days ago6 Dec: $97, found 2 days ago15 Dec: $98, found 3 days ago16 Dec: $103, found 3 days ago29 Dec: $99, found 2 days ago30 Dec: $144, found 5 days agoDec
See the chart as a table
The cheapest price seen for each departure date — per traveler in Economy.
DatesFromAirlineAirportsStopsFound
1 Dec$96Porter Airlines CanadaNewark Liberty International Airport (EWR) → Pearson International Airport (YYZ)1 stopfound 4 hours agoOpen this trip
5 Dec$105Porter Airlines CanadaNewark Liberty International Airport (EWR) → Toronto City Centre Airport (YTZ)1 stopfound 7 days agoOpen this trip
6 Dec$97Porter Airlines CanadaNewark Liberty International Airport (EWR) → Toronto City Centre Airport (YTZ)nonstopfound 2 days agoOpen this trip
15 Dec$98Porter Airlines CanadaNewark Liberty International Airport (EWR) → Toronto City Centre Airport (YTZ)1 stopfound 3 days agoOpen this trip
16 Dec$103Porter Airlines CanadaLaGuardia Airport (LGA) → Pearson International Airport (YYZ)nonstopfound 3 days agoOpen this trip
29 Dec$99Porter Airlines CanadaNewark Liberty International Airport (EWR) → Toronto City Centre Airport (YTZ)1 stopfound 2 days agoOpen this trip
30 Dec$144Porter Airlines CanadaNewark Liberty International Airport (EWR) → Toronto City Centre Airport (YTZ)1 stopfound 5 days agoOpen this trip

Which month looks cheapest?

January 2027 is the cheapest month — from $84.

November 2026From $1003 departure dates27 Nov · found 3 days agoOpen this trip
December 2026From $967 departure dates1 Dec · found 4 hours agoOpen this trip
January 2027From $84Cheapest seen3 departure dates18 Jan 2027 · found 3 days agoOpen this trip
February 2027From $1371 departure date19 Feb 2027 · found 4 days agoOpen this trip
March 2027From $1092 departure dates15 Mar 2027 · found 2 days agoOpen this trip
May 2027From $1222 departure dates31 May 2027 · found 4 days agoOpen this trip
June 2027From $1711 departure date16 Jun 2027 · found 2 days agoOpen this trip

Prices are what travelers' searches on Aviasales found in the last 7 days, in US dollars: the price the seller showed on Aviasales; bags may cost extra. Fares change, so check today's price before you book. How our prices work